Is commercial or residential real estate better?

A brass balance scale on a walnut desk weighs a white clapboard house model against a red-brick shop building model
Uriel Manseau

CTO, Sphera Credit

B.Eng., M.Sc. Applied Mathematics

Reviewed by Joseph Edelmann, CEO, Sphera Credit

9 min read

Is commercial or residential real estate better?

Neither is better for every investor. Residential real estate is the easier first purchase, and commercial real estate suits a buyer with more capital, more time and a building whose rents can carry its own loan. The choice turns on four questions: how much cash you have, how you want to borrow, how much work you want to do and how you want the building taxed.

For lending, the line sits at the fifth unit. A house or a building of up to four units is residential real estate. An apartment building of five or more units joins offices, shops and industrial buildings on the commercial side. The commercial real estate glossary defines the terms this page uses.

QuestionResidential: one to four unitsCommercial: five or more units, offices, shops, industrial
What does the lender underwrite?Your income, debts and creditThe building's net operating income
What does a buyer who will not live there put down?15% to 25% in the US, 20% in Canada20% in the US and 15% in Canada, when the rents support the loan
Who pays property tax, insurance and repairs?The landlord, under most leasesOften the tenant, under a triple net lease
Who are the tenants?HouseholdsBusinesses, or households in an apartment building
What work falls on the owner?Repairs and tenant turnoverLease talks, fit-outs and usually a property manager
How fast does the building depreciate for tax?US: 27.5 years. Canada: 4% a yearUS: 39 years for non-housing. Canada: 6% for eligible non-residential buildings

Why do investors say commercial real estate is better than residential?

Investors who prefer commercial property point to four features:

  • Longer leases. A business tenant signs for several years, so the owner faces fewer turnovers than with households on yearly leases.
  • Tenants who carry costs. Under a triple net lease, the tenant pays its share of property tax, insurance and maintenance on top of base rent. The guide to triple net leases shows how each cost passes through.
  • A loan sized on the building. A commercial lender measures the building's net operating income, the rent left after operating costs and before loan payments, against the loan payment. Strong rents can carry a loan that the owner's salary could not.
  • Value that follows income. Buyers price a commercial building from its income, so an owner who raises rents or cuts costs raises the building's value.

The same features cut the other way. A vacant store can sit empty for months, and a landlord often pays for the next tenant's fit-out through a tenant improvement allowance. A residential landlord re-rents a unit with paint and cleaning.

How much do you need to put down on a rental house or an apartment building?

A buyer who will not live in the building puts down 15% to 25% on a US residential property and 20% in Canada. A building of five or more units can need less, 20% with Fannie Mae and 15% with CMHC insurance, when its rents cover the loan. The second figure surprises most buyers, because guides on the topic say commercial property always needs more cash.

Loan-to-value is the loan divided by the property's value, and the down payment is the rest. In the US, Fannie Mae caps an investment-property purchase at 85% of value for one unit and 75% for two to four units (Fannie Mae, Eligibility Matrix). Its multifamily arm lends on existing buildings of five or more units with a maximum loan-to-value of 80% and a minimum debt service coverage of 1.25 (Fannie Mae Multifamily, small loan term sheet).

In Canada, OSFI's Guideline B-20 applies to all federally regulated financial institutions that underwrite home loans. By law, a home loan above 80% of the property's value must be insured (OSFI, Guideline B-20). CMHC's homeowner insurance covers a building of one to four units when at least one unit is owner-occupied (CMHC, homeowner insurance). For rental buildings, CMHC insures projects with at least five rental units up to a maximum loan-to-value of 85% (CMHC, rental housing insurance).

Building, for a buyer who will not live thereLender or insurerHighest loan-to-valueLowest down payment
US, one unitFannie Mae85%15%
US, two to four unitsFannie Mae75%25%
US, five or more unitsFannie Mae Multifamily80%, with coverage of at least 1.2520%
Canada, one to four unitsFederally regulated lender, uninsured80%20%
Canada, five or more unitsCMHC rental housing insurance85%15%

Why can a fifth unit lower the down payment?

A lender sizes the loan on a five-unit building from its rents, so the building's income decides the down payment. The debt service coverage ratio divides net operating income by the year's loan payments, and the debt service coverage test caps the loan where the ratio falls to the lender's minimum.

Take two buildings priced at $1,000,000, a fourplex and a five-unit building, both financed at an assumed 6.5% interest rate over 30 years:

  • The fourplex. Fannie Mae lends up to $750,000 to an investor, so the buyer puts down $250,000. The buyer's own income has to qualify for the payments.
  • The five-unit building at full leverage. An $800,000 loan costs $60,678 a year. At a coverage of 1.25, the building needs net operating income of at least $75,848 to borrow the full 80%.
  • The five-unit building earning $60,000. The coverage test caps the loan at $632,843, so the buyer puts down $367,157, or 36.7% of the price.

Down payment on a $1,000,000 building at an assumed 6.5% rate over 30 years: 25% for a fourplex at any income, against 42% for a five-unit building earning 5.5% of its price, falling below 25% above 7.1% and reaching the 20% floor at 7.6%

Source: Sphera Credit calculation on a $1,000,000 price at an assumed 6.5% rate over 30 years, with Fannie Mae's limits: 75% loan-to-value for an investor's two- to four-unit purchase (Eligibility Matrix) and, for five or more units, 80% loan-to-value with a debt service coverage of at least 1.25 (Small Mortgage Loan Program term sheet).

At that rate, the five-unit building needs less cash than the fourplex once its net operating income passes about 7.1% of the price. Below that yield, the fourplex is the cheaper building to buy with a loan, because its loan rests on the buyer's income.

How do taxes treat residential and commercial rental buildings?

The US writes off a rental housing building over 27.5 years and other buildings over 39 years. Canada favours the other side: housing takes 4% a year, and an eligible non-residential building can take 6%. Depreciation spreads a building's cost over years of tax deductions, and Canada calls its version capital cost allowance. Both countries leave land out of the deduction.

For tax, use decides the side. The IRS treats a building as residential rental property "if 80% or more of its gross rental income for the tax year is from dwelling units" (IRS, Publication 946). An apartment building of any size therefore takes the 27.5-year schedule, even though lenders call it commercial. Offices, shops and industrial buildings take 39 years.

The CRA places most buildings in Class 1, at 4%. It adds 2% for other eligible non-residential buildings, for a total of 6%, and 6% for a building used to manufacture or process goods, for a total of 10% (CRA, depreciable property classes). The owner has to elect to put the building in a separate class to claim the higher rate. Under proposed changes, a new building built as a purpose-built residential rental may qualify for an accelerated rate of 10%.

Here is what each rule allows on $1,000,000 of building cost, land excluded:

Deduction on $1,000,000 of buildingRental housingOffice, shop or industrial
US, each full year, straight line$36,364 over 27.5 years$25,641 over 39 years
US, first 10 full years$363,636$256,410
Canada, most a year can claim on $1,000,000 of undepreciated cost$40,000 at 4%$60,000 at 6%

The US figures ignore the mid-month rule that trims the first year. In Canada, each year's claim falls as the undepreciated balance shrinks. Both countries tax the depreciation back when you sell, which the guide to the tax on a commercial property sale works through.

Which is better for a first-time real estate investor?

Residential real estate is the usual first step, because an owner who lives in one unit borrows on home-loan terms. Fannie Mae lends up to 95% on a two- to four-unit home its owner lives in, and CMHC insures up to 95% on one or two units and 90% on three or four. Those limits sit in the same Fannie Mae matrix and CMHC rules as the investor limits above, under the rows for an owner-occupied home.

Match the building to your cash, your time and your experience:

  • Small savings, hands-on. Live in one unit of a duplex, triplex or fourplex and rent the others. The loan follows home-loan rules, and the tenants' rent helps carry it.
  • A full investor down payment, no wish to live on site. A rental house or a small multi-unit building keeps the purchase small, and a lender judges your own income.
  • More capital and a track record. A building of five or more units can borrow on its rents. In Canada, CMHC asks the borrower for "five years' multi-unit property management experience (or a property manager with this record)" and a net worth of at least 25% of the loan (CMHC, rental housing insurance).
  • Income with no building to run. Shares of a real estate investment trust or a crowdfunding offering give you a stake in commercial buildings, and the guide to real estate investment trusts covers what they pay and how they trade.

CMHC also asks the borrower to guarantee 100% of the loan until the building has 12 consecutive months of stable rents. A first-time buyer of a five-unit building in Canada should expect to hire a property manager to meet the experience test.

What do people get wrong when comparing commercial and residential real estate?

Three beliefs run through most comparisons: that commercial property always earns more, that it always needs a bigger down payment, and that its tenants always pay the building's costs. Each one fails against the price record or the lenders' own rules.

Does commercial real estate always earn more than residential?

Investor guides that promise higher commercial returns rarely name a source, and the measured record runs both ways. Over the last US cycle, house prices rose much faster than commercial property prices, as the comparison of commercial and residential price swings shows. Returns also differ widely between the types of commercial property, so "commercial" covers several markets that move apart.

Does a commercial building always need a bigger down payment?

A five-unit apartment building can take less cash than a fourplex at both Fannie Mae and CMHC. The rents decide it: a building whose income falls short of the coverage test gets a smaller loan, and the buyer covers the gap.

Do commercial tenants always pay the building's costs?

Commercial tenants pay those costs under a net lease. A tenant on a gross lease pays one rent, and the landlord pays the property tax, insurance and upkeep out of it, as a residential landlord does.

Frequently asked questions

Investors who prefer commercial real estate point to longer business leases, tenants who pay property costs under net leases, and loans sized on the building's income. Those same features bring longer vacancies, fit-out costs for new tenants and more complex loans. Whether they make commercial property the better choice depends on your capital, your experience and the time you can give the building.

Sources

  1. Fannie Mae: Eligibility Matrix — Fannie Mae (checked 2026-11-18)
  2. Fannie Mae Multifamily: Small Mortgage Loan Program term sheet — Fannie Mae (checked 2026-11-18)
  3. OSFI: Guideline B-20, Residential Mortgage Underwriting Practices and Procedures — Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (checked 2026-11-18)
  4. CMHC: Mortgage loan insurance, CMHC Purchase — Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (checked 2026-11-18)
  5. CMHC: Mortgage loan insurance, standard rental housing — Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (checked 2026-11-18)
  6. IRS: Publication 946, How To Depreciate Property — Internal Revenue Service (checked 2026-11-18)
  7. CRA: Classes of depreciable property — Canada Revenue Agency (checked 2026-11-18)

Educational disclaimer

Educational content only. This is not financial, tax or legal advice. Consult a licensed professional for guidance specific to your situation.